Samourai Wallet says feds hid advice that crypto mixer was in the clear
By: bitcoin ethereum news|2025/05/07 00:30:04
0
Share
Samourai Wallet’s lawyers allege federal prosecutors suppressed advice that the firm didn’t need a license before they charged executives at the crypto mixing service months later. In a May 5 letter to a Manhattan federal court, lawyers for Samourai co-founders Keonne Rodriguez and William Hill said prosecutors disclosed that the US Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) representatives told them six months before they charged the pair “that under FinCEN’s guidance, the Samourai Wallet app would not qualify as a ‘Money Services Business’ requiring a FinCEN license.” “Shockingly, six months later, the same prosecutors criminally charged Keonne Rodriguez and William Hill with operating just such a business without a FinCEN license,” the lawyers added. The letter claimed that prosecutors were required to share their discussions with FinCEN over Samourai two weeks after they unsealed charges, making the deadline May 8 last year, but instead “suppressed this information for over a year, disclosing it only on April 1, 2025.” Prosecutors charged Samourai CEO Rodriguez and its technology chief Hill with conspiracy to operate an unlicensed money transmitting business and money laundering conspiracy in February 2024, unsealing the charges and arresting the pair in April that year. Samourai’s mixing service took crypto from multiple users and blended it together to hide its origins. The government alleged the platform helped with over $2 billion in illegal transactions and facilitated over $100 million worth of money laundering transactions from online black markets and scammers. Rodriguez and Hill both pleaded not guilty. In the letter, their lawyers said prosecutors shared details of a call with Kevin O’Connor, chief of FinCEN’s Virtual Assets and Emerging Technology Section in the Enforcement and Compliance Division, and Policy Division staffer Lorena Valente. According to an email from one of the prosecutors summarizing the call, FinCEN said that “because Samourai does not take ‘custody’ of the cryptocurrency by possessing the private keys to any addresses where the cryptocurrency is stored, that would strongly suggest that Samourai is NOT acting as an MSB [money services business].” The email said O’Connor and Valente agreed that the government could try to argue that Samourai functionally controlled the crypto, “but that has never been addressed in the guidance, and so it could be a difficult argument” for prosecutors. Samourai’s lawyers asked the court for a hearing “to determine the circumstances surrounding the Government’s late disclosure” and to administer a remedy. Samourai to renew dismissal bid if case goes on Rodriguez and Hill’s lawyers said that, using this latest information, they would again ask for the charges to be dismissed, arguing they lacked fair notice and “understood they were acting lawfully.” Related: US Treasury’s OFAC can’t restore Tornado Cash sanctions, judge rules Prosecutors and Samourai asked the court for more time on April 28 to consider potentially dismissing the case after the Justice Department rolled back its crypto enforcement. Rodriguez and Hill bid to dismiss the case in early April, arguing it should be dropped as Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche said in an April 7 memo that the Justice Department wouldn’t prosecute crypto mixers for “unwitting violations of regulations.” In the latest letter, their lawyers said if the government “were to resist the Blanche Memo’s directive and push forward,” then they would bid to dismiss as “if they were not money transmitters under FinCEN’s guidance, then they could not possibly be prosecuted for not having a license.” Magazine: Tornado Cash 2.0 — The race to build safe and legal coin mixers Source: https://cointelegraph.com/news/samourai-wallet-feds-hid-advice-crypto-mixer-didnt-need-license?utm_source=rss_feed&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=rss_partner_inbound
You may also like

Trading Never Sleeps: On-Chain, Crude Oil, and Leverage
The prices in this window are determined by emotions, amplified by leverage, driven by the narrative of war—rather than by the supply and demand of crude oil.

On-chain Yield Panorama: The Evolution from Interest-bearing Stablecoins to Crypto Credit Products
In a bear market, investors tend to prefer more stable returns and lower underlying risks, which has driven the growth of interest-bearing stablecoins.

RootData announced the integration with OpenClaw, and these gameplay features have gone viral
In the era of AI Agents, the value of data lies not in "ownership," but in "connection."

Key Market Intelligence on March 9th, how much did you miss out on?
1. On-chain Funds: $221M flowed into Hyperliquid last week; $186.7M flowed out of Arbitrum
2. Largest Price Swings: $DENT, $UAI
3. Top News: Middle East Conflict Sparks Stagflation Trading, Global Stock Markets Shed Around $6 Trillion

a16z: After AI Superpowers, Where to Next for Humanity?
Cryptocurrency will become the cornerstone of trust in this new era.

Why Does Oil Go Up When Bitcoin Goes Down?
The Impact of Middle Eastern Oil on Bitcoin Price

Decoding 112,000 Polymarket Addresses: The Top 1% Making Money Are Doing These Five Things
Those loss-making addresses are not stupid, just lacking discipline — too many markets involved, overexposure, excessive FOMO, and hardly any post-mortem.

AAVE founder issues a warning: DeFi must never become the exit liquidity for Wall Street private credit
In order for RWA to succeed in DeFi and for DeFi to achieve meaningful scale expansion through real-world assets, the entire industry needs to thoughtfully and cautiously build opportunities that connect TradFi (traditional finance) and on-chain markets.
How To Create A Frequency So Strong It Makes Reality Obey You
The first-ever WEEX AI Hackathon has concluded, with 10 winners emerging from over 200 global teams. Beyond its $1.8 million prize pool, the event marked a milestone—proving that the future of AI trading belongs to accessible, AI-powered innovation.

The cryptocurrency industry has waited for five and a half years, and what they got is half a ticket
The hand that opens this door is not the rule, but the direction of the wind.

The trend of Ethena reveals what information about the cryptocurrency market
Through Ethena's data insights: the collective hedging and self-protection of VCs and project parties is leading the crypto market into an extreme risk-averse moment of "complete balance between bulls and bears" for the first time in history.

I've been in the crypto industry for five and a half years, and all I got was half a ticket.
The hand that opens this door is not a rule, but a wind.

Crude Oil Surges 25%, Hyperliquid Unfolds On-Chain Showdown
Hyperliquid users now need to keep an eye on the latest developments in the Iran Hormuz Strait, while a DeFi OG is using on-chain derivatives to hedge against war risk.

$20 Billion Valuation, Is Kalshi Engaging in an Arms Race with Polymarket?
US-Iran Conflict + World Cup + Eve of Elections, Predicts Market Key Data Points to Reach New All-Time Highs in 2026.

Will Not Messing with OpenClaw Lead to Obsolescence in the AI Era? | Lobster Fuss Summit
Amazon Web Services On-Site Guidance to Deploy OpenClaw, Low-Cost and User-Friendly

Anticipating the Market's New Challenge to Political Elections
The next US presidential election will depend on the prediction markets

The Shadow Business Empire of Iran's New Supreme Leader: Oil, Real Estate, and Financial Intrigue
From political and military influence to shaping the financial network, Mujataba has secretly laid the groundwork to assume the ultimate leadership position.

Next-Generation Software Built for Trillion-Agent Scale
When the Agent becomes a key user of the software, software design, infrastructure, and business model will all change accordingly
Trading Never Sleeps: On-Chain, Crude Oil, and Leverage
The prices in this window are determined by emotions, amplified by leverage, driven by the narrative of war—rather than by the supply and demand of crude oil.
On-chain Yield Panorama: The Evolution from Interest-bearing Stablecoins to Crypto Credit Products
In a bear market, investors tend to prefer more stable returns and lower underlying risks, which has driven the growth of interest-bearing stablecoins.
RootData announced the integration with OpenClaw, and these gameplay features have gone viral
In the era of AI Agents, the value of data lies not in "ownership," but in "connection."
Key Market Intelligence on March 9th, how much did you miss out on?
1. On-chain Funds: $221M flowed into Hyperliquid last week; $186.7M flowed out of Arbitrum
2. Largest Price Swings: $DENT, $UAI
3. Top News: Middle East Conflict Sparks Stagflation Trading, Global Stock Markets Shed Around $6 Trillion
a16z: After AI Superpowers, Where to Next for Humanity?
Cryptocurrency will become the cornerstone of trust in this new era.
Why Does Oil Go Up When Bitcoin Goes Down?
The Impact of Middle Eastern Oil on Bitcoin Price